How will Chico handle homelessness 20 months from now?

It's not too soon to plan, councilmember says
By Yucheng Tang | Posted May 18, 2025

photo by Karen Laslo

An officer tells a homeless woman at Humboldt and Forest that she must move from the encampment.

Councilmember Addison Winslow, at the next City Council meeting, says he will push for a study of Gov. Gavin Newsom’s ordinance designed to guide cities that are struggling to manage homeless encampments.

Last week, Gov. Newsom released what he called a “model ordinance” that can be used to “address unhealthy and dangerous encampments.” The ordinance provides a framework local jurisdictions can use to remove encampments from public spaces, and permits speedier enforcement than the framework the City uses now under the Warren v. Chico Settlement Agreement.

For example, the so-called model ordinance requires that officials or officers post a notice 48 hours before taking enforcement actions, “except in exigent circumstances involving an imminent threat to life, safety, health, or infrastructure.” In contrast, the Settlement Agreement mandates 7-day notice to Legal Services of Northern California prior to enforcement planning, 7-day notice to homeless persons who are camping on public property, and finally, a 72-hour notice prior to enforcement. read more

New Council sub-committee discusses the “shelter-resistant”

Community members who spoke hold out hope for people who seem challenging to help
By Yucheng Tang | Posted May 3, 2025

photo by Yucheng Tang
Behavioral Health Director Scott Kennelly speaks at the first meeting of the City’s ad hoc committee on homelessness.

At the first meeting of the City’s ad hoc committee on homelessness, the discussion touched on the overlap between homelessness, substance abuse and mental health. It also raised two related questions: how to address the problem of shelter-resistant homeless individuals, and whether compelled treatment is sometimes necessary.

Scott Kennelly, the director of Butte County Behavioral Health, said homeless outreach teams have worked to convince unhoused people to take advantage of services and have tried to connect them with services, but there are always people who say, “Leave me the hell alone.”

In his view, homeless people who refuse to go to shelters can generally be divided into three groups: those severely addicted to drugs like Fentanyl and Xylazine who are solely focused on their next hit and refuse any care; those with severe mental illness who are psychotic and unaware of their condition; and those who prefer a rule-free lifestyle.

“There’s almost no one left out there who is not severely addicted to a substance, is severely mentally ill, or has (not) made a lifetime style choice,” Kennelly said.

But Charles Withuhn, president of the North State Shelter Team, said that beyond the categories Kennelly mentioned, there is also a group of people “who will be OK with accountability.” He said he talked to a man who was sleeping in the bushes the other day, and that man told him while crying, “All I need is a door that locks and a little bit of job training, and I will go to work.”

Withuhn, who advocates for smaller programs where homeless people can build and find community, said there are still some unsheltered individuals who want help. “There’s too many people having too many bad experiences in big programs, and they feel like they lose their autonomy.”

Amber Abney-Bass, CEO of the Jesus Center, shared statistics about the people who have been served at the Genesis emergency pallet shelter housing. Since April 2022, 423 people have been served. During 2024, 69% reported having a disability, 33% had a chronic health condition, and 39% reported a mental health disorder, she said. Additionally, 51% said they struggled with addiction, alcohol use or both.

Julian Zener, a community member who was attending the April 30 meeting, asked whether some of the people who seem to be shelter-resistant could be persuaded otherwise, warning against what he called “writing off all the people out there.”

“People who currently turned down offers, you related to three categories that seemed to be sort of irredeemable, and I wonder if there’s part of that fourth category, as Charles suggested, that if we could find out more of their story, and build trust, and they might turn around,” Zener said.

Michael O’Brien, one of three councilmembers on the committee, commented on his impression of the service-resistant population.

“Getting them help is really the challenge,” O’Brien said. “And when you have someone who is not thinking correctly, it’s really difficult to get [something] across to them. You just have to understand how powerful these [drugs] are that are dominating their life.”

The new ad hoc committee is chaired by Mayor Kasey Reynolds, with councilmembers Bryce Goldstein and O’Brien as the other members.

Goldstein asked Kennelly how the underlying issues that are keeping people from accessing services can be addressed.

“You have to pair the treatment and the housing at the same time,” he said.

In terms of treatment, he said he has, over time, shifted his philosophy.

“I’m at a point where I say, ‘You have the opportunity through every possible resource to get help,'” Kennelly said. “You’re not willing or you’re not able to see you need it. Now someone has to come in and help support you like a parent or a big brother or a conservator.”

He mentioned mental health diversion court, drug court, and Stepping Stones Perinatal Program — three programs that can compel or press people to receive treatment — and said he saw the most powerful graduation in Stepping Stones.

Behavioral Health hopes to purchase a motel or hotel in the community to house people who are facing felony charges but have been found incompetent to stand trial, where they can receive support and intensive treatment to restore competency. Such a program would typically last about 18 months, said Kennelly, adding, “At least they won’t be on the streets.”

Kennelly also mentioned that a mental health rehabilitation center will be established this year.

The committee will meet biweekly on Wednesdays from 3-4:30 p.m. until summer, when it will report its findings and recommend action to the full City Council panel. The next meeting is scheduled on May 14 in the city hall conference room.

Yucheng Tang is a California Local News fellow reporting for ChicoSol.

How a judge decided to leave Settlement Agreement intact

A frustrated mayor responds; an advocacy organization for the unhoused applauds ruling
By Yucheng Tang | Posted April 4, 2025

photo by Leslie Layton
The Comanche Creek encampment was removed years ago.

In September of last year, the City of Chico began another legal journey – this time an effort to exit the Warren v. Chico Settlement Agreement.

On March 31, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California denied the City’s motion, which means the City has to abide by the five-year agreement that started in 2022 and ends in 2027.

The Settlement Agreement prohibits the City from enforcing anti-camping ordinances when adequate shelter is unavailable. In planning an eviction of unhoused campers from public spaces, the City must make a count of available shelter beds, advise plaintiff counsel Legal Services of Northern California (LSNC) and notice campers who will be assessed and referred elsewhere. Some City officials consider the process unnecessarily onerous.

The settlement was the result of a 2021 lawsuit against the City and its police department filed by Legal Services, a legal aid agency. The lawsuit argued that the City was violating the rights of homeless people when it razed encampments.

The order says that the City voluntarily entered the agreement and failed to demonstrate any changed circumstances that warrant the granting of relief.

Viewpoints on the ruling differ
Some City leaders and homeless advocates view this recent ruling in different ways.

After seven months of waiting for the court ruling, Chico Mayor Kasey Reynolds said she was disappointed that the City’s motion was denied.

“While we respect the judicial process, we firmly disagree with the Court’s ruling,” Reynolds said. “This will continue to limit the City’s ability to timely and effectively address the public safety issues in the City.”

In an emailed statement, Reynolds wrote that the City is reviewing the Court’s decision and evaluating its legal options going forward. “I would not rule out any possibility at this time, however cost and time will need to be carefully considered with any and all decisions made on the City’s behalf,” she said.

Reynolds also noted that this agenda falls into the “Existing Litigation” category, meaning that it will only be discussed in closed session rather than publicly at the City Council meeting.

LSNC, which represented the eight unsheltered people in the Warren v. Chico case, said it is pleased that the court held the City of Chico to the obligations it agreed to in the Settlement Agreement.

Will Knight, decriminalization director at the National Homelessness Law Center, views the recent Warren v. Chico ruling as good news. He is part of the team of attorneys and advocates dedicated to protecting the rights of the homeless and solving homelessness.

“Despite the shameful ruling in Grants Pass, it remains counterproductive, morally corrupt, and legally unwise for cities to arrest or fine people for living outside when they have nowhere else to go,” Knight said.

City watched U.S. Supreme Court ruling
The City’s motion followed the Supreme Court’s decision in the Grants Pass v. Johnson case, which overturned its previous ruling and allowed cities to evict and penalize individuals sleeping in public, even when no alternative public spaces or shelters are available.

“Instead of wasting taxpayer dollars by passing or enforcing laws that make it illegal to be homeless or reopening settled cases,” Knight said, “elected officials in Chico and across the country must focus on proven solutions to homelessness, like housing and care.”

But the Supreme Court’s ruling became one of the key arguments in the City of Chico’s motion.

The City contended that “it is inequitable for the Settlement Agreement to remain
unmodified because the decision in Grants Pass would not constrain their enforcement of the Anti-Camping Ordinances,” according to the judge’s order.

The court was not persuaded. “This is because defendants voluntarily entered into the Settlement Agreement, thereby agreeing to assume obligations beyond the minimum constitutional requirements, and did so for the purposes of resolving the litigation,” the order explains.

The court order also says that the City failed to demonstrate that some public safety issues, like fires and crimes, have worsened after entering the Settlement Agreement.

LSNC pointed out that “the overwhelming majority of unhoused people who have talked with us say they would stay at the Pallet Shelter if they were offered a spot, yet it is our understanding that the Shelter has never once filled since it opened.”

Members of the public indicated concern about the City’s approach to homelessness during the March 4 City Council meeting. Felix Mahootian protested the ongoing eviction sweeps launched by the City. “As it stands, the sweeps do nothing to help leverage folks out of homelessness who are there,” Mahootian said. “These are just enforcement, not preventive.”

In fact, despite the Settlement Agreement’s restrictions on ordinance enforcement, the City has published 15 notices of planned enforcement of camping ordinances since February 2024.

An unhoused man ChicoSol spoke with during the Feb. 27 eviction sweep at City Plaza said he didn’t know where to move his belongings. He said he might relocate to a parking lot or under tree cover for a few days. In the end, he said, he would return to City Plaza.

The man said he preferred the Genesis pallet shelter emergency housing over the Torre Community Shelter for its greater freedom. Though he had been repeatedly offered a Torres Shelter bed, he preferred to remain unsheltered.

“We look forward to continuing to work with the City to improve conditions and access to shelter for Chico’s unhoused residents, particularly by increasing opportunities for unhoused people to enter the Pallet Shelter,” says the LSNC statement.

Yucheng Tang is a California Local News Fellow reporting for ChicoSol.

Developers file lawsuit against City of Chico

Effort underway to void referendum and move forward Valley's Edge
By Leslie Layton | Posted April 2, 2025

photo by Leslie Layton
The land east of city limits transitions into the foothills.

The Valley’s Edge development group has filed a lawsuit in Butte County Superior Court against the City of Chico, arguing that the 2024 referendum that has blocked its project from going forward must be voided.

The Believe in Chico LLC says that the state’s Housing Crisis Act of 2019 is grounds for voiding the referendum and allowing the development of 2,700 housing units and 57 acres of commercial development on vacant land east of city limits.

In a March 5 election last year, more than 60 percent of Chico voters opposed two measures related to the planned development known as Valley’s Edge.

The lawsuit filed March 20 in Butte County Superior Court and received by the City of Chico today argues that “housing shortfalls have reached crisis levels,” and adds that this city is “no stranger to this emergency.” It states that the Housing Crisis Act legislation prohibits passage of any kind of policy that stops housing development in the jurisdiction of an “affected city.”

“The Act applies to the ‘electorate of an affected county or city exercising its local initiative or referendum power,’” states the lawsuit, quoting a statute.

Believe in Chico LLC is what was formerly known as Chico Land Investment. It says the project was approved by the City and in keeping with the 2030 General Plan. It also notes that the City planned to annex the property.

The lawsuit says a “controversy has arisen” with the City over the “lawfulness of the Referendums.” The lawsuit was filed by a Los Angeles firm on behalf of Douglas Guillon and Believe in Chico.

Valley’s Edge, as it was originally planned, could place almost 5,600 people in southeast Chico where the valley floor transitions into foothills.

Chico resident Eric Nilsson, who worked on the Stop Valley’s Edge campaign with the group Smart Growth Advocates, said last year that volunteers who canvassed met voters who were clear about their misgivings. “What we found out is that what Chicoans don’t want is sprawl development that’s going to put more pressure on the infrastructure of the City,” Nilsson told ChicoSol.

Earlier this year, Butte County Superior Court Judge Michael Candela predicted that Valley’s Edge would be back in one form or another, and he placed a stay on a lawsuit filed by environmental groups Sierra Club, the Center for Biological Diversity and AquAlliance.

“The court believes there is a high likelihood that a new project will take the place of the former Valley’s Edge project,” the judge said in denying the City’s motion to dismiss the suit. “… this court has been around this county for a very long time. The issues from this case are unlikely to go away. However, the case is stayed until further order of the court.”

Leslie Layton is editor of ChicoSol.

Warren Settlement Agreement left intact by federal judge

By Yucheng Tang | Posted April 1, 2025

U.S. District Court Judge Dale A. Drozd has denied the City of Chico’s motion for relief from final judgment in the case Warren v. Chico.

The case led to a settlement agreement in 2022 that prohibited the City from enforcing anti-camping ordinances when adequate shelter was unavailable. The City later sought to modify or terminate that agreement, citing changes in the law (the Grants Pass v. Johnson decision by the U.S. Supreme Court) and changed circumstances, such as public health and safety concerns.

The court order says the City failed to prove that some public safety issues, like fires and crimes, have worsened after entering the Settlement Agreement.

“It is undisputed by the parties that the number of fires attributable to homeless people in general has been reduced during the operation of the Settlement Agreement compared to the number that took place prior to their entry into the Settlement Agreement,” the order says. “…nor have they presented evidence showing that the level of crime in Chico has changed since their entry into that agreement.”

District 4 Councilmember Addison Winslow commented in an Instagram post.

“What the judge gave us is the resounding rejection of everything that the City claimed,” Winslow says.

“We can negotiate a plan that can outlast the Settlement Agreement so we find a way to really workably handle homelessness in our community,” Winslow said, “or we can sit and complain.”

This story will be updated in the coming days.

Homelessness complicated by shortage of services

Accessing mental health services a challenge for the homeless
By Carina Merrick | Posted March 18, 2025

photo by Karen Laslo

“I never know what day it is. I only know the time based on whether the sun is out.”

I (Melissa) was alarmed by this statement from an unhoused individual I interviewed as I helped with Butte County’s 2025 Point in Time (PIT) count, the biennial study that measures the number of unhoused persons through observation and response to a survey about their needs. This man was describing the challenges he faced in seeking mental health services at a walk-in facility. He was given an appointment for months out, making it impossible for him to attend because he had no reliable way to tell time.

Based on the accounts of this individual and others, it is common for unhoused people to be unable to access critical mental health and housing services due to overcrowded facilities. As social work students, we are concerned about this issue because it negatively impacts not just the unhoused population, but our community as a whole.

According to the 2023 PIT data, there are about 925 unhoused individuals in Chico. Although multiple homeless shelters exist, 40% of these unhoused persons are unsheltered.

Thirty-eight percent of unhoused individuals in Chico experience mental health issues, while the overall rate in California is even higher — at 50%-60%. Because there are insufficient shelter options and mental health services, this population is susceptible to engaging in substance abuse as a coping mechanism, or crime, including theft, to address their unmet needs.

The increase in substance abuse can lead to potential harm to themselves and others or possible overdoses. Higher rates of violence and crime can trigger negative psychological effects due to fear and safety concerns on the part of members of our community. Also, the lack of hygiene facilities for unsheltered individuals causes unsanitary conditions in public spaces where these persons are living.

During the March 4 Chico City Council meeting, community members echoed these safety concerns while also recognizing the issue of homelessness as a top priority. Currently, a large portion of the budget allocated to addressing homelessness is spent on clearing encampments, which is not only inhumane but also ineffective at solving the problem in the long run. The solutions brought to the Council’s attention were creating managed campgrounds, forming safe parking areas, and increasing the number of shelters.

In addition to supporting these solutions, we urge the new ad hoc homelessness committee to advocate for access to walk-in mental health services at managed campgrounds, facilities and shelters. We implore these organizations to train individuals to be culturally aware and sensitive to issues faced by unhoused persons.

We encourage shelters and law enforcement agencies to conduct regular crisis intervention training for staff to provide better support around substance abuse and mental health issues. We urge shelters to address intake, record keeping and communication issues so that unhoused individuals have consistent housing. Through these solutions, we can create a safer environment and improve the quality of life not only for unhoused individuals, but also for the community as a whole.

Melissa Herzstein is a resident of Chico and a first-year student in the Master’s of Social Work (MSW) program at the University of Southern California (USC). She volunteered to help with the PIT count, which she said was “eye-opening for me because it showed me how much mental health services for individuals experiencing homelessness are needed. I came across multiple individuals who mentioned their struggles with mental health and wished I could have done more than provide referrals to facilities they already knew of.”

Amy Ballard is a Los Angeles resident who is also enrolled in the MSW program at USC. Ballard said: “Based on our research, the aspect of homelessness in Chico that stood out to me the most was the long wait times for unhoused individuals to receive mental health services at walk-in facilities. Through the efforts of the ad hoc committee on homelessness and other community endeavors, we hope that the unhoused population will be able to obtain more timely and accessible services in the future.”