Measure E Supporters Canvassed to Ban Fracking in Butte

By ChicoSol staff | Posted May 30, 2016
Melinda Vasquez
 

photo by Karen Laslo

 Melinda Vasquez takes a break from canvassing


Editor’s Note:  Measure E to ban hydraulic fracturing in Butte County had passed with 71.5 percent of the vote, according to election results on June 8. This story was written during spring semester at Chico State.

Melinda Vasquez knocks on a door at the sea-green apartment complex. She is greeted by a woman, who notifies her Chihuahua she’s “going to spank your butt” if the dog doesn’t stop barking. The dog quiets down.

Vasquez begins her inquiry: Whether her neighbor is familiar with the Yes-on-Measure-E campaign to ban fracking, a question she’s asked dozens of times at doors in the Memorial Neighborhood of Chico just in the last hour. read more

Meeting with a Chef on the Road to Adulthood

By Carina Merrick | Posted May 4, 2016

Chef Thomas Rider
photo by Gabby Miller

Chef Thomas Rider prepares Strawberry Caprese Crostini with local strawberries.

He stood before a crowd of college students and alumni. On the table in front of him was a basket full of fresh fruits and vegetables displaying the colors of the rainbow. A grey Chico State Wildcats baseball cap sat on his head, and his black chef’s jacket was lined with red trim and embroidered with his name and title on the front.

It read: “Thomas Rider, Executive Chef.”

“I’m on the Food Network at Chico State,” he said, receiving chuckles from the audience.

On the rainy Thursday evening before spring break more than 60 students arrived at CSUC’s Bell Memorial Union to watch Rider—the executive chef for Associated Students—put on a show.

 “There’s no magic here tonight,” Rider joked. “Just simple ingredients to make delicious food.”

The demonstration was the fourth installment of “Adulting 101,” an eight-part workshop hosted by Student Life and Leadership, the Career Center and the Alumni Engagement Office.

Those in attendance for Rider’s presentation first walked by a small, round table set up with a jug of water, granola bars, fruit snacks and cookies as they made their way to a seat. There they found recipe cards detailing the night’s three courses: Strawberry Caprese Crostini, Farmer’s Market Salad and Pasta with Oyster Mushrooms and Greens.

Rider’s inspiration for the menu came as he contemplated how to make his presentation “adult.”

“Here in Chico, we live in this wonderful agricultural mecca,” he said. “We’re surrounded by fields and livestock and all kinds of delicious things.”

A majority of the food Rider used came from either the Saturday morning Chico Farmers Market or the North Valley Food Hub to show students that supporting local farmers and business is a mutually beneficial decision.

“That was my approach—to try and elicit a community teaching method,” he said.

During the demonstration of the first course Rider roused a chorus of “oohs” and “ahhs” when he held up a bright red strawberry the size of his palm.

“Where can I get those fat strawberries?” an audience member inquired.

Rider told the man he’d picked them up from the local Farmer’s Market and received a dissatisfied response.

“But those are like 10 bucks.”

Audience members debated whether or not the product was worth the price. Some felt that it was too expensive, but many agreed that they would hand over $10 for the strawberries.

Rider then quickly informed the crowd that he was able to buy enough food for the event to feed about 60 people and spent less than $100 in doing so. The price didn’t include certain items—the pasta used in the main course, for example—but Rider stressed that buying fresh fruit and vegetables from local farmers isn’t as expensive as one might think.

As he cooked, Rider answered many more questions about the different types of vegetables he was using while explaining the steps of the recipe in detail. Audience members were able to try a sample of each course after watching it be prepared.

The first course was a play on a Caprese salad — it usually consists of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil and the colors of the ingredients are meant to resemble the Italian flag. Rider took inspiration and created his Strawberry Caprese Crostini: strawberries, queso fresco and basil, drizzled with balsamic vinegar and served over slices of toasted baguette.

Rider’s Farmer’s Market Salad featured fresh, crisp greens and vegetables all locally grown. He shared techniques for how to prepare the dish, including tearing the greens with one’s hands instead of using a knife to prevent bruising and discoloration.

Rider was surprised at the number of people who showed up and was happy to share his knowledge.

“It was really positive; the crowd was engaging,” he said. “Food is my life. Anyone who is interested is a bonus to me.”

One audience member with interest was Danie Schwartz, a recent Chico State graduate who is on the Alumni Association Board of Directors.

“[The demonstration] was informative and easy enough that the average person could do it,” she said.

The Adulting 101 program came about with the help of Mary Wallmark, the program coordinator for Student Life and Leadership. A big audience that Wallmark wants to reach is young alums—a target group that was reached with Schwartz, who attended the food workshop to show support for her alma mater.

Wallmark and others joined together when they saw a need for programs that provide students with skills that they can’t receive in the classroom. “You’re not going over banking in a class,” she said. “But this isn’t just about money management; these are life skills.”

Adulting 101 got its name from being what Wallmark describes as a “funny concept.” She stressed that the ultimate goal is the accessibility factor for students. “You don’t have to be perfect when you come to this stuff,” Wallmark said. “This is your life. We’re all trying to do our best; we all have different levels of skill.”

Workshops that preceded the one on healthy cooking included discussions on basic finance, budgeting skills and identifying personality styles. Wallmark said there was high interest in the series even before the first workshop was held, allowing them to expand their ideas beyond original plans. The series was planned to start off with basic concepts and progress in difficulty with each workshop building off ideas addressed previously.

Program coordinators grouped budgeting skills with healthy cooking to demonstrate that it doesn’t take much money to eat fresh foods rather than sticking to food out of a box or can.

This will be just one aspect that is added next school year when the series is expanded from eight workshops to 16. Wallmark said the plan is to include a healthy cooking presentation both semesters and she has already recruited Rider to lead the presentations again. She hopes to help students better themselves in all aspects.

“The more you can manage your life the easier it is to be academically successful,” Wallmark said. “If we’re not going to do this—who will?”

Gabby Miller is a Chico State senior majoring in public relations who wrote this story for the Magazine Writing class.  As a student journalist, she’s covered a wide range of topics, some of which you can find on her blog.

 

 

Garcia’s Fight Shapes California Law

By Leslie Layton | Posted August 6, 2015


photo by Karen Laslo

 


Sergio C. Garcia came to California packed onto the bed of a Chevy pick-up. It was July 4, 1994, and the 17-year-old was one of eight undocumented Mexican immigrants hidden under a hard plastic cover as they crossed the U.S. border under a blazing desert sun.

Garcia prayed out loud as fellow travelers passed out from the heat. He was sweat-drenched and seething at his father, who had asked him to make the perilous journey, to relocate for the second time to a country where he would be labeled “alien” and face the barriers associated with having crossed, without a visa, the world’s most frequently-crossed international border. read more

County Goof Shaped Fracking Debate

By Leslie Layton | Posted July 1, 2015
SnellingsCalarco_251_276

photo by Leslie Layton

 


One of the key arguments made during the local fracking debate was based, at least in part, on an erroneous statement by county officials, ChicoSol has learned.

As a draft ordinance to prevent fracking was debated at public meetings early this year and last year, opponents often argued that a Butte County ban would serve a symbolic rather than regulatory role. The Butte County Department of Development Services (DDS) provided a key piece of evidence for that argument: No one, they said, had applied for a conditional use permit to drill a new gas well in more than 25 years.

But ChicoSol, working with partner Chico News & Review, has learned that for 22 of those 25 years, conditional use permits weren’t sought from the county for an astonishingly simple reason: They weren’t required. Butte County didn’t require conditional use permits for gas-well drilling until it adopted a new zoning code on Nov. 6, 2012. read more

How the Fight to Ban Fracking Turned Partisan

By Leslie Layton | Posted February 23, 2015

It cost the oil-and-gas industry some pocket change (about $100 grand) to accomplish its mission in Butte County. If I had a leaked memo, the mission might have been described this way: Stop cold the county’s ordinance to ban fracking, reframe their debate.

On Feb. 10, the Board of Supervisors rejected a 13-page ordinance to ban fracking written by Butte County attorneys who had conducted research over a period of months. Chair Doug Teeter and supervisors Steve Lambert and Bill Connelly said they had changed their position on the issue — but not because of “threats” as had been suggested.

What was even more remarkable was the partisan pitch the debate had acquired. The fracktivists who have been on an almost two-year quest to achieve a local ban were sometimes treated as a fringe group or a cog in a larger, more ominous movement. Or as citizens seeking a political statement on a national issue of no consequence to Butte County.

When the board voted April 8 to draft an ordinance that would ban fracking, it seemed the 4-1 vote would place Butte County at the vanguard of a statewide, grass-roots movement. The supervisors reasoned (with the exception of Larry Wahl, the supe who consistently opposed a ban) that an ordinance would ensure that a frack job would never endanger the region’s groundwater or threaten the county’s agricultural character.

Butte County doesn’t have oil, but it has small natural-gas deposits and 32 wells that are either active or idle. Its geology isn’t amenable to horizontal drilling, the technique that has given hydraulic-fracturing projects their scale in other parts of the country. But small-scale fracking has been underway in neighboring counties, and county staff recommended on Feb. 10 adoption of the ordinance.

Instead, the trio of supervisors withdrew their support, moving the board toward a decision that the CN&R called “gutless,” and the Enterprise-Record said would “fail the citizenry” and ensure that voters would pass a weaker ordinance that will be on the ballot in June 2016. Supervisor Maureen Kirk became the lone board member in favor of moving ahead with a ban. Lambert, who made the motion in April to draft an ordinance, said he had worried about a lawsuit by some “big, scary corporation” to challenge what he now viewed as a symbolic gesture.

Lambert was reluctant to give environmentalists a victory even if he agreed with them in principle. “This one is very hard for me,” Lambert said at the Feb. 10 meeting. “I truly don’t like fracking, but I have problems with being part of a bigger movement. I don’t want to be the trendsetter. My concern is we’re doing this for the wrong reasons, we’re trying to start this whole freedom-fighter thing.”

How did the quest by a diverse group of citizens who make up Frack-Free Butte County become a “freedom-fighter thing”?

It took $116,238 — the amount that was spent in Butte County after the April vote, according to Secretary of State campaign-disclosure forms — and some help from the county’s conservative political machine to polarize the debate and roust members of the board. It probably wasn’t any single thing: Not the yard signs that sprang up or the robocalls to conservative voters; Not the citizens who argued in favor of private-property rights; Not just the interventions by large out-of-town law firms.

Given that at least two of the supervisors were concerned about legal trouble, you could infer, though, that the industry-funded political action committee (PAC), Californians for Energy Independence, was successful. The campaign-disclosure reports show the PAC was receiving millions of dollars in contributions from companies like Chevron, Vaquero Energy and Freeport-McMoRan Oil and Gas to fight local movements in California to restrict fracking.

(Though an ordinance to ban fracking that was on the November ballot in Santa Barbara County failed, bans have been imposed in Santa Cruz, San Benito and Mendocino counties.)

Teeter said because fracking isn’t “imminent” in Butte County, he now viewed the ordinance as a “political statement.” Later, he told me that he doesn’t want to act when the state hasn’t yet completed an independent study that’s underway, and he wants to see how San Benito County’s fracking ban withstands legal challenges.

Dave Garcia, a Sierra Club activist who helped launch the local anti-fracking movement, believes that if natural gas prices increase enough, fracking will be attempted here. “Now’s the time to put regulations in,” Garcia said, “when we don’t have large corporations investing in our county. Once they’re invested we’ll never get them out.”

Between May and October, Butte County got a sense of what it means to confront the state’s most powerful corporate lobby. In May, a mailer opposing the ban appeared around Butte County, funded by the PAC and signed by Sen. Jim Nielsen (R-Gerber).

During the next two months, the PAC funneled a total of $47,500 to a pair of local Republican strategists as opposition to a ban mounted at public hearings. Then came what the fractivists called “The Suits.” Two corporate law firms became players in the Butte County debate, both of which earned tens of thousands of dollars last year working for Californians for Energy Independence opposing bans in Santa Barbara, San Benito and other counties.

The San Rafael firm Nielsen Merksamer Parrinello Gross & Leoni challenged Frack-Free Butte County’s ballot initiative on grounds that it had technical defects, but a judge dismissed the challenge. The Los Angeles law firm Latham & Watkins sent a letter to the county in October stating that Butte’s ordinance to ban fracking is illegal under state law.

Butte County Counsel Bruce Alpert believes the ordinance his staff drafted will stand up in court, but the ordinance drafted by citizens as a ballot referendum may not. The citizens’ ordinance that will appear on the June 2016 ballot, he said, is “flawed.”

The Butte County ban movement has always been a grass-roots, underfunded effort. It began in summer 2013 with a group called Citizens Action Network that includes retirees, professionals, college students and long-time environmental activists. The Frack-Free Butte County organization emerged to gather signatures for a ballot initiative.

“That effort is what brought the Board of Supervisors to want to do something on their own,” noted Marty Dunlap, an attorney who volunteers with a water-advocacy group. “We thought this was a way to work with county supervisors to put protections in for our most valuable resource, groundwater. It didn’t seem like it was going to be that big a deal.”

San Benito County anti-fracking activists managed to win voter approval in November for a ban ordinance that had been drafted by a San Francisco law firm. But it was a very big deal, said Andy Hsia-Coron, a founder of the anti-fracking group San Benito Rising.

Hsia-Coron said that the oil-and-gas industry, with the help of Republican groups, outspent his side by 14-1 and tried to make the ban proponents look like extremists. “We kept saying, ‘We don’t look like who you say we are,'” Hsia-Coron told me by telephone. “Their money became ineffective.”

At the Feb. 10 meeting, Lambert, who farms in this region, said sectors of his industry had been “constantly under fire by extremes.”

“My ag friends agree with me,” Lambert continued. “They don’t like fracking either, but have the same concerns with being part of a bigger movement.”

Connelly said he was uncomfortable with the larger anti-fracking movement and concerned about energy independence. Then came this sweeping statement: “The less we rely on crazy people overseas that burn pilots and behead people, the better off the country is.”

Kirk moved to adopt the county’s ordinance, but her motion died for lack of a second as supervisors discussed alternatives, like a ban on waste disposal and more well-drilling use-permit conditions.

A few days after the meeting, I spoke with Teeter by telephone and he predicted that larger amounts of industry money will flow into the county prior to the June 2016 referendum on fracking. And if the board bans fracking, he believes that PAC money could fund candidates who would promise to overturn the ordinance. “Do we really want one-issue candidates?” Teeter said. “A ban would be a lot stronger if citizens imposed it.”

But Supervisor Kirk has pointed out that the citizens’ ordinance will be more difficult to defend in court. Teeter says the activists could undertake a new campaign to place the ordinance drafted by county staff on the November 2016 ballot.

The steering committee for Frack-Free Butte County will meet Wednesday to discuss a strategy, but not everyone seems eager to start anew. They know what it means to collect 10,000 signatures without paid signature-gatherers, to face legal challenges from corporate law firms without legal assistance, to hold bake sales and wine-tastings to pay campaign costs.

Garcia balked at Teeter’s suggestion. “They fumbled the ball,” Garcia said of the supervisors. “Now they want us to do their work for them?”

Leslie Layton is a freelance writer who has covered fracking and other issues. Contact her at chicosolnews@gmail.com and follow her on Twitter @ChicoSolNews

Family Stories, not Census Forms, Explain Ethnic Identities

By ChicoSol staff | Posted February 18, 2015
Gail_101_121

“Are you Hispanic?” isn’t supposed to be a tough question. Yet every time I meet it while completing a census form or medical history, my pencil hovers between “Yes” and “No” and my eyes search for the most accurate answer, which is never there: “Sort of.”

I’m one of the millions of Americans who occasionally change their ethnic designation. It’s complicated. My mother’s father emigrated with his family from Mazatlán, Mexico, when he was in his teens. He married my grandmother — not Hispanic — in Los Angeles in the late 1920s, and they had two daughters. My grandfather’s family was big, noisy, and still firmly tied to the Mexican state of Sinaloa. When my curly-haired Aunt Gloria was a little girl, the family took her there at festival time and dressed her as an adorable seńorita. My mother and Gloria grew up in southern California in the 1940s and ’50s with a Spanish surname and were sometimes told, in those racist “good old days,” that they were “not like the other Mexican girls — you’re clean.” How could that history not be a part of our heritage? read more